Your song rating, broken down.
Songwriting, vocals, production, originality and commercial potential. See what holds up—and what holds you back.
THINK IT’S
A BANGER?
Find out how good your music really is.
Upload your song. Choose your AI music reviewer. Get a brutally honest song review with scores, detailed feedback and practical ways to improve your music. Then take it further with feedback from the Grumpy Music community and optional chats with human industry experts.
User reviews
This really helped me thank you! I knew the song was nice but something felt off and now i figured it out!
Major-label perspective. Independent-artist focus.
Founded by Ted Criborn, former Creative Director at Universal Music.
01 / The verdictListen. Dissect. Improve.
Honest reviews.
Finally.
Inside your AI song review
Your audio. Under the microscope.
Loudness, dynamics, tonal balance and peaks are measured before the review is written.
Know where you stand.
See how your song’s rating compares with other tracks reviewed in your genre.
Music feedback you can use.
Understand the reasons behind your song’s rating, with practical suggestions for your next version.
02 / The critics’ deskThree perspectives. Your track.
Choose your song reviewer.
Everyone’s a critic.
Pick yours.
01The industry ear
The Grumpy A&R
Song identity, commercial potential and the industry perspective.
Choose Grumpy A&R when you want to understand where your song fits in the market.
02The studio ear
The Producer
Creative risk-taking, lyrical imagery and sound design.
Choose the Producer when you want to explore the creative choices that make your track your own.
03The analytical ear
The Analyst
A measured assessment of your track’s strengths and weaknesses.
Choose the Analyst when you want a detailed assessment of what works and what needs attention.
Inside their reviews
Hear the difference
in their feedback.
Three separate public reviews of “Ni ville mig väl” by Måd. These excerpts show what each AI reviewer chose to focus on.
“You've got an immediate vocal hook in the first ten seconds, the song clocks in under three minutes, and your lyric writing is ten times smarter than ninety percent of the stuff landing in my inbox.”Read the Grumpy A&R review
“The unprepared modulation to G major isn't just a music theory trick; it's the emotional core of the track, a perfect marriage of craft and intent.”Read the The Producer review
“The only minor point of critique is that some synth textures, while effective, feel slightly generic compared to the highly characterful bass and vocal work.”Read the The Analyst review
Each review reflects the version and context submitted. Your review uses one AI reviewer of your choice.
From your studio
to the critics’ desk.
- 01Pick an ear. Send your track.
Upload your song and choose an AI music critic for a detailed review of your track.
- 02Let the community weigh in.
Get human song feedback from listeners who answer questions as your track plays.
- 03Talk it through.
Discuss your music review with a human industry expert and decide what to work on next.
03 / A note from the founderBetter feedback. Better music.
Meet the Founder
Hi there! I'm Ted a former Creative Director at Universal Music and a tech nerd that got tired of bad feedback so i built Grumpy!
Join the Community
Get honest music feedback from real listeners. Hear what connects, what doesn’t, and why.
Explore the music feedback community14,774
AI-Reviews Created
894
Community Reviews Given
Before you hit play
Good questions. Honest answers.
Can AI listen to my song and give feedback?
Grumpy Music analyses your uploaded audio to create a song review with ratings, written feedback and suggestions for improvement. Choose an AI music reviewer whose perspective fits what you want to learn. Treat the review as another perspective, alongside your own judgment and feedback from human listeners.
Can I get feedback on a song made with Suno?
Yes. Export your song from Suno and upload the audio file to Grumpy Music. Choose one of our three AI reviewers for a song rating and feedback on your track’s strengths and areas to improve, including songwriting, lyrics, arrangement and production. You can also share your track with the Grumpy Music community for feedback from human listeners.
How do I choose the right song reviewer?
Choose Grumpy A&R for an industry perspective on your song’s identity and commercial potential. Choose the Producer for creative risk-taking, lyrical imagery and sound design. Choose the Analyst for a measured assessment of your track’s strengths and weaknesses. Each review uses the critic you select, so start with the perspective that best fits what you want to learn.
How does AI rate my song?
Your chosen AI reviewer analyses your uploaded track and gives it an overall rating, category scores and written feedback explaining its assessment. The emphasis and categories vary by reviewer. Different critics can value different things, so read the reasons behind the numbers. A song rating is a starting point for understanding your music, not a prediction of commercial success.
What can I do with the music feedback?
Use the music critique to choose what to work on next: a lyric that needs a clearer image, an arrangement that loses momentum or a production choice worth revisiting. Listen back with the feedback in mind and decide which suggestions serve your song. You can also seek feedback from real listeners or discuss your review in an optional paid chat with a human industry expert.
Enough about us. Let’s hear you.
YOUR TRACK.
OUR HONEST OPINION.
One free review.
Find out whether it’s a banger.
No credit card required.